& Google Break Up

Google Checkout Makes Shopping Sites Undesirable

As Google Checkout ramps up, many thin arbitrage / shopping aggregator sites are going to see a significant love loss from Google. In September Andrew Goodman wrote a piece on how paid search and organic search quality criteria may play off each other, after coming across a post on Inside AdWords where Google stated that some types of sites are likely to merit a low quality score:

The following types of websites are likely to merit low landing page quality scores and may be difficult to advertise affordably. In addition, it's important for advertisers of these types of websites to adhere to our landing page quality guidelines regarding unique content.
  • eBook sites that show frequent ads
  • 'Get rich quick' sites
  • Comparison shopping sites
  • Travel aggregators
  • Affiliates that don't comply with our affiliate guidelines

Market Saturation

It does not help any of the shopping aggregators that there are about a dozen competitors (BizRate,, Shopzilla, MSN Shopping, NextTag, Epinions, DealTime, Pricegrabber, Pricerunner, Yahoo! Shopping, etc.). From a marketing standpoint almost all of them offer near identical user experience, so few of them are remarkable or linkworthy. The whole field (including Yahoo!) compete based on renting large swaths of links.

Everyone MUST Rent Links to Compete

Given Google's recent war cries against buying and selling links, and that there are so many shopping comparison sites, it is easy for Google to whack a few of them with it going unnoticed by anyone outside the companies. But if you are in the comparison shopping field and do not rent links, how can you compete with Yahoo! when they do? You can't.

The Fall of

I am uncertain if the drop in Google was algorithmic or editorial, but BizRate's Alexa ranking is off sharply over the past couple weeks, and if you look at top keywords they ranked for on Google (via, SEO Digger, or SpyFu), their site is no longer ranking for many of them. In fact, I didn't even see the US site ranking for "biz rate". For that term ranks #1. When I visit the UK site from a Google search result for "biz rate" the site asks if I want to view the US site or the UK site.

Here is a snapshot of the plunged BizRate traffic

And here is a running historical graph:

Google's Algorithmic Whitelists Are Not Carved in Stone

BizRate, which sold to the E.W. Scripps company for $525 million, used to be on Google's editorial white list.

Published: November 13, 2007 by Aaron Wall in publishing & media


November 13, 2007 - 9:49pm

It's true that each one of these sites is just like the other,. However, as a concept they are quite helpful. I don't think I buy any electronics without checking one of the biz rate like sites at least once.

Google... What are they thinking?

November 14, 2007 - 12:11am

yep, not to mention the fact that in some less-saturated markets (eg. mine in Australia) comparison shopping sites still provide great value and there aren't too many clones -- however the change in Google policy doesn't seem to care about intricacies like this...

November 16, 2007 - 3:22am

A few weeks ago I received a panicked-sounding email from bizrate saying to put nofollow condoms on any bought links that pointed to their site. Just sayin'.

November 16, 2007 - 3:31am

And it looks like their Google rankings came back the day after I made this post, as you can see by the tick upward in their Alexa ranking.

November 16, 2007 - 7:27pm

It seems to me that this is just because they were buying links. Because I think price comparison sites are very relevant (not all of them - some are worthless). Also the main price comparison sites are spending millions in advertising.

I don't see why a price comparison site that is well-designed with original content shouldn't have a good quality score.

Google must not have them as a bad quality score at this point as they are still spending as much as they usually do.

November 16, 2007 - 10:21pm

Google must not have them as a bad quality score at this point as they are still spending as much as they usually do.

True, but this is still a shot across the bow. A warning that they are not immune. Few site's of BizRate's scale have felt the wrath of Google.

Add new comment

(If you're a human, don't change the following field)
Your first name.
(If you're a human, don't change the following field)
Your first name.
(If you're a human, don't change the following field)
Your first name.